I've been curious about why seemingly conservative Republicans across the Virginia blogosphere seem to dislike and mistrust Mike Huckabee so much.
To a Democrat, like me, he would seem to appeal most perfectly to a strong part of their base, the evangelical social conservatives. Indeed, that was a key to his victory in Iowa and will be a large part of his appeal in South Carolina. Yet Republican bloggers are all over the map, with Kat, from Cathouse Chat, staunchly supporting Duncan Hunter, somebody who doesn't have a realistic chance in any primary. Jim Hoeft and Squeaky Wheel, of Bearing Drift, issued a joint endorsement of Mitt Romney a few weeks ago. And Mason Conservative was originally for Fred and then switched to Rudy.
So, what is it about Mike Huckabee that turns off these often socially conservative Republicans?
Fred Thompson gave this rather succinct wrap up explaining why party insiders dislike and mistrust Huckabee, whom conservatives like Leslie Carbone dismiss, as she did in this scathing post.
On the other hand, I've got to say in Huckabee's defense, he's no Democrat despite Thompson's attempt to portray him as such. Nor is he a liberal.
But there is a small but growing segment of young evangelicals who are disaffected with the Christian Right.
They care about issues like responsible stewardship of the environment, poverty and economic justice, racism, and peace. They are disaffected from the culture wars.
They are not liberal on abortion and they don't support gay marriage. But they are also tired of the demonization of gay people and the politicization of those wedge issues to the exclusion of other concerns.
These new Christians eschew the conservative or liberal labels and are part of a movement called the emergent church movement. Their leaders include Brian McLaren, Tony Campolo, and Jim Wallis.
Although some Democrats have been hoping to lure these leaders into a closer alliance with the Democratic Party (I'm one of those who supported this), there are things about Huckabee that might appeal to the idealistic young people who make up a large part of this new movement within the evangelical churches.
There are, however, serious impediments to Huckabee picking up their support if you look below the surface of Huckabee's populist appeal.
For example, his fair tax proposal, which is a flat tax, favors the wealthy and would be burdensome to the middle class and the poor. In addition, he has made statements about gays and AIDS that hark back to the culture wars that this group is so tired of.
But Huckabee's bass playing, folksy appeal could play beyond the narrow evangelical base. And that's what's scaring traditional no-tax, let's constantly fight the culture wars conservatives who truly comprise the hard right of the Republican Party.
Showing posts with label Mike Huckabee. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Mike Huckabee. Show all posts
Saturday, January 12, 2008
Friday, January 04, 2008
The Audacity of Hope Trumps Anger and Experience
The overwhelming message to come out of the Iowa primary was that voters are hungry for change. Both Barack Obama and Mike Huckabee won convincing victories. And in both parties the hunger for the new and different trumped the desire for experience and overthrew the establishment candidate.
There was another strong message in the subtext, however, that should give strong encouragement to the Democrats and raise the alarm bells among Republicans. I’ll get to that in a moment.
But first to go back to the Democratic side of the race, a secondary story is that Barack Obama’s message of hope, not only beat Hillary Clinton’s message of experience. It also trumped Edwards’ angry populism. Edwards played to the most liberal and angry part of the Democratic base. By contrast, Obama brought in first time caucus goers, many of whom were independents and young people. Turning out the young has been a nearly impossible feat in previous Iowa primaries, which favor the older, more established and activist voters. But most interesting of all was the fact that he even pulled in some Republican moderates.
In general, more people participated in the Democratic caucuses than in the Republican ones by 239,000 to 125,000 votes. That means that roughly 65% of all voters chose to caucus as Democrats and only 35% caucused with the GOP.
That means that independents are identifying more with the Democrats than Republicans, which is something political pundits have been picking up for a while. But more startling is that moderate Republicans decided to come out to the Democratic caucuses.
In some years, I might worry that this was part of a GOP strategy to throw the Democratic primary to the weakest candidate, ensuring an easier contest for their own choice in the general election. But that only happens when the Republican Party doesn’t have a competitive race of its own.
That’s not the case here. The Republican primary was as highly contested as the Democratic one was and just as fluid. So, those Republicans who decided to change affiliation and caucus with the Democrats may well have given up on their own party’s choices, at least for this election cycle. That can’t bode well for the GOP for the general election.
Obama won the Democratic caucuses by bringing in new people and broadening the party’s base. Huckabee, on the other hand, brought out a narrow segment of religious voters and won his caucuses by narrowing the Republican base.
I’m not sure how that affects the rest of the primaries and the general election but coming out of Iowa there were some interesting results and the beginning of a trend. We may well be seeing that people are tired of the status quo and want change. But they don’t want anger or divisiveness. In fact, that may be the very part of the status quo that they are rejecting the most. They want a president with fresh ideas, concern for economic justice, and the ability to get along with others to get things done in a pragmatic way. The change those Iowa caucus goers may have voted for was the end to the culture wars and the beginning of solutions to the problems that everyday people face, like the economy, health care, pension reform, and bringing the troops back from Iraq.
And above all, the voters seem not to want anger as much as they want inspiration. That’s a very American choice.
There was another strong message in the subtext, however, that should give strong encouragement to the Democrats and raise the alarm bells among Republicans. I’ll get to that in a moment.
But first to go back to the Democratic side of the race, a secondary story is that Barack Obama’s message of hope, not only beat Hillary Clinton’s message of experience. It also trumped Edwards’ angry populism. Edwards played to the most liberal and angry part of the Democratic base. By contrast, Obama brought in first time caucus goers, many of whom were independents and young people. Turning out the young has been a nearly impossible feat in previous Iowa primaries, which favor the older, more established and activist voters. But most interesting of all was the fact that he even pulled in some Republican moderates.
In general, more people participated in the Democratic caucuses than in the Republican ones by 239,000 to 125,000 votes. That means that roughly 65% of all voters chose to caucus as Democrats and only 35% caucused with the GOP.
That means that independents are identifying more with the Democrats than Republicans, which is something political pundits have been picking up for a while. But more startling is that moderate Republicans decided to come out to the Democratic caucuses.
In some years, I might worry that this was part of a GOP strategy to throw the Democratic primary to the weakest candidate, ensuring an easier contest for their own choice in the general election. But that only happens when the Republican Party doesn’t have a competitive race of its own.
That’s not the case here. The Republican primary was as highly contested as the Democratic one was and just as fluid. So, those Republicans who decided to change affiliation and caucus with the Democrats may well have given up on their own party’s choices, at least for this election cycle. That can’t bode well for the GOP for the general election.
Obama won the Democratic caucuses by bringing in new people and broadening the party’s base. Huckabee, on the other hand, brought out a narrow segment of religious voters and won his caucuses by narrowing the Republican base.
I’m not sure how that affects the rest of the primaries and the general election but coming out of Iowa there were some interesting results and the beginning of a trend. We may well be seeing that people are tired of the status quo and want change. But they don’t want anger or divisiveness. In fact, that may be the very part of the status quo that they are rejecting the most. They want a president with fresh ideas, concern for economic justice, and the ability to get along with others to get things done in a pragmatic way. The change those Iowa caucus goers may have voted for was the end to the culture wars and the beginning of solutions to the problems that everyday people face, like the economy, health care, pension reform, and bringing the troops back from Iraq.
And above all, the voters seem not to want anger as much as they want inspiration. That’s a very American choice.
Tuesday, January 01, 2008
Slick Mikey is Too Clever By Half
Perhaps it's something they put in the water in Arkansas or maybe it's just that there's more to the stereotype of the shrewd country horse trader that outsmarts the big city slickers; but Mike Huckabee's most recent example of sly, sneaky misdirection has nothing on Bill Clinton and anything he might have pulled when Republicans dubbed him Slick Willie. So, if nobody else has given Huckabee the nickname yet, let me be the first. He's earned the title Slick Mikey.
As the Washington Post reported here, Huckabee called a press conference in Iowa to unveil an attack ad against Mitt Romney. The ad criticized Romney's honesty in stark terms.
Before going any further, let me say that there was absolutely nothing wrong with Huckabee publicly hitting Romney about his flip flops. This was not an attack on Romney's religion, his lifestyle, or his family. It was in no way a personal condemnation.
Romney spent his political career in Massachussetts running as a moderate pro-business Republican who was liberal on social issues. Both in his Senate race against Ted Kennedy and his later run for governor he supported abortion rights and gay rights. He even attempted to run to the left of Kennedy in 1994 on support for equal treatment of gays.
He began to tack right only in 2005 when his presidential aspirations became well known. At that time he also vetoed a bill to legalize the morning after pill in Massachussetts. What he did angered voters there. In fact, it was also pulling a switch and bait on those who voted for him in the gubernatorial election based on the view that he was a pro-choice moderate.
If he did that to voters in his home state, it's fair to ask if those he now courts can trust him. He needs the social conservatives to get the Republican nomination. But what would happen if, in the general election, he discovers that some of his newly found conservative values are less popular and are a drag on his ambitions. Does he jettison them yet again?
Voters who care about abortion, gay rights, and stem cell research on both sides of those issues do deserve to know that Mitt Romney has flipped flopped on this.
But what makes Mike Huckabee's campaign tactic so reprehensible is its pure dishonesty. Of course he wants to make the point that Romney can't be trusted. If he didn't, he simply would have decided quietly not to run the already prepared ad. He'd have killed it and not said anything.
Instead he's trying to have it both ways. In fact, here's what Washington Post reporters Michael Shear and Perry Bacon reported:
He wants to get out the message and evade responsibility for being the messenger. He didn't approve the message but he sure wants the public to know 1) what the message is; and 2) he took the high road and didn't spread it.
Of course, the press wasn't buying it as they made clear in their coverage of the press conference. And neither should you buy it.
Most values voters know that honesty is a value too.
As the Washington Post reported here, Huckabee called a press conference in Iowa to unveil an attack ad against Mitt Romney. The ad criticized Romney's honesty in stark terms.
Before going any further, let me say that there was absolutely nothing wrong with Huckabee publicly hitting Romney about his flip flops. This was not an attack on Romney's religion, his lifestyle, or his family. It was in no way a personal condemnation.
Romney spent his political career in Massachussetts running as a moderate pro-business Republican who was liberal on social issues. Both in his Senate race against Ted Kennedy and his later run for governor he supported abortion rights and gay rights. He even attempted to run to the left of Kennedy in 1994 on support for equal treatment of gays.
He began to tack right only in 2005 when his presidential aspirations became well known. At that time he also vetoed a bill to legalize the morning after pill in Massachussetts. What he did angered voters there. In fact, it was also pulling a switch and bait on those who voted for him in the gubernatorial election based on the view that he was a pro-choice moderate.
If he did that to voters in his home state, it's fair to ask if those he now courts can trust him. He needs the social conservatives to get the Republican nomination. But what would happen if, in the general election, he discovers that some of his newly found conservative values are less popular and are a drag on his ambitions. Does he jettison them yet again?
Voters who care about abortion, gay rights, and stem cell research on both sides of those issues do deserve to know that Mitt Romney has flipped flopped on this.
But what makes Mike Huckabee's campaign tactic so reprehensible is its pure dishonesty. Of course he wants to make the point that Romney can't be trusted. If he didn't, he simply would have decided quietly not to run the already prepared ad. He'd have killed it and not said anything.
Instead he's trying to have it both ways. In fact, here's what Washington Post reporters Michael Shear and Perry Bacon reported:
"I pulled the ad. I do not want it to be run at all," he said. But within minutes, the ad was being played on national television and had been posted on blogs and other Web sites -- without costing his campaign a penny.
He wants to get out the message and evade responsibility for being the messenger. He didn't approve the message but he sure wants the public to know 1) what the message is; and 2) he took the high road and didn't spread it.
Of course, the press wasn't buying it as they made clear in their coverage of the press conference. And neither should you buy it.
Most values voters know that honesty is a value too.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)